Skip to main content

Groups & meetings

Hotels.com® Rewards

Open app

List your property Support Trips

Members save 10% or more on over 100,000 hotels worldwide when you’re signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it’s free

Feedback

125 Properties in Shelter Island Historical Society, Shelter Island, New York, United States of America. ${startDate} through ${endDate}

Where to?

Dates

Travelers

Room 1

Adults

ChildrenAges 0 to 17

Need to book 9 or more rooms?

Sort & Filter

Compare properties

Get a side-by-side view of up to 5 properties.

Search by property name

e.g. Marriott

Traveler experience

Eco-certifications

LGBTQ welcoming

Business friendly

Family friendly

Adults only

Luxury

Budget

Wedding

Romantic

Beach

Guest rating

Guest rating

Any

Wonderful 9+

Very good 8+

Good 7+

Star rating

2 stars

3 stars

4 stars

1 star

5 stars

Stay options

Stay options

Any

Hotels

Homes

Accessibility

Service animals allowed

Elevator

Accessible bathroom

Wheelchair accessible parking

Stair-free path to entrance

Roll-in shower

Sign language-capable staff

In-room accessibility

Property type

Capsule Hotel

Ranch

Pousada

Pousada (Brazil)

Castle

Safari

Hostel/Backpacker accommodation

Resort

TownHouse

Hotel

Pension

Tree house

Ryokan

Bed & breakfast

Aparthotel

Cottage

Camping

Condo

Residence

Country House

Farm

Hostal

Palace

Cruise

Motel

Riad

Holiday Park

Guesthouse

Lodge

Inn

Chalet

Condo resort

Cabin

Villa

Private vacation home

Apartment

Houseboat

Amenities

Cribs

Air conditioned

Airport shuttle included

Ocean view

Spa

Wifi Included

Restaurant

Washer and dryer

Casino

Kitchen

Hot tub

Outdoor space

Water park

Bar

Parking

Pool

Pet friendly

Electric car charging station

Golf course

Gym

Meal plans available

All inclusive

Dinner included

Lunch included

Breakfast included

Hotels.com Rewards

VIP Access properties

A collection of top-rated stays

Member Prices

Get instant savings when you're signed in

Discounted properties

Major discounts on selected stays

Total price

Min

Max

$0, Minimum, Total price

$1,000 and above, Maximum, Total price

Popular filters

Popular

Payment type

Reserve now, pay later

Property cancellation options

Fully refundable property

Availability

Only show available properties

Neighborhood

Neighborhood

Shelter Island

Shorewood

Silver Beach

Montclair Colony

Coecles Harbor

Menantic Creek

Hay Beach

Room views

Room views

Harbor view

Park view

Pool view

Ocean view

Canal view

Lake view

Marina view

Hill view

Valley view

Bay view

Lagoon view

Beach view

Water view

River view

Desert view

Garden view

Courtyard view

Mountain view

Vineyard view

City view

Golf course view

Resort view

125 properties

How our sort order works

Search results

House on Chase Creek

Shelter Island Heights

Fully refundable

9.49.4 out of 10

Exceptionalexceptional

77 reviews(77 reviews)

The current price is $185

$185

includes taxes & fees

More information about House on Chase Creek, opens in a new tab

One Bedroom Harbor View Terrace Suite | View from room

The Harbor Front Inn

Breakfast included
Pool

8.88.8 out of 10

Excellentexcellent

524 reviews(524 reviews)

12% off

The current price is $219

$219

includes taxes & fees

More information about The Harbor Front Inn, opens in a new tab

The Menhaden

Breakfast included

Fully refundable

9.69.6 out of 10

Exceptionalexceptional

167 reviews(167 reviews)

The current price is $359

$359

includes taxes & fees

Sign in for extra savings

More information about The Menhaden, opens in a new tab

Loading